The actual series finale of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is a good piece of television. Buffy’s line about cookie dough. The amulet. Spike. The school bus. Sunnydale swallowed by the earth it was built on. It ends with possibility — the world changed, potential Slayers awakened everywhere, Buffy free for the first time.
It is not, however, the ending the series deserved.
That ending came two years earlier, in Season 5. “The Gift” — the hundredth episode of the show, originally written as a series finale before the move to UPN — is everything a conclusion should be. Buffy Summers dies. Not dramatically, not in a blaze of apocalyptic spectacle, but by walking off a platform because she cannot let her sister bleed out in her place. The portal closes. The headstone reads: She saved the world a lot.
Seven words that contain the entire series.
What makes “The Gift” work as an ending is not just the sacrifice but the shape of the season that precedes it. Season 5 is constructed around death in a way the show had never fully committed to before. Joyce’s illness arrives without dramatic warning and resolves in the most ordinary and devastating way possible. “The Body” exists. Buffy’s encounter with the First Slayer, the vision quest, the realisation that her gift is not what she initially thinks — all of it builds toward someone finally understanding what it means to be a Slayer, and accepting it. The season is about learning to die well. It completes that thought.
Seasons 6 and 7 are not bad television. Season 6 is, in patches, extraordinary — the Willow arc in particular is the show at its most uncompromising. But it is also television that undoes what “The Gift” achieved. Buffy’s friends tear her out of heaven and she spends a year in the wreckage of that decision. The serenity of her sacrifice is retroactively poisoned. This was a deliberate choice, and there are good arguments for it. It is still a choice that costs the show something it cannot entirely recover.
Giles understands this better than anyone, which is perhaps why his decision in “The Gift” — quietly, coldly finishing what Buffy could not — lands with the weight it does. He does what heroes cannot do, so that Buffy can remain one. It is the season’s final act of love, and it belongs in an ending, not a pause.
There is a version of Buffy the Vampire Slayer that ends on that platform in Sunnydale, with the sun coming up and a girl who has given everything, and a line about the world being saved. That version of the show does not need to answer what comes next. It is complete.
We got a longer version. Parts of it are magnificent. But the perfect ending was already there.
Leave a Reply