There are levels of dead in Hollywood. There is “the character is dead but we could bring them back,” which is more or less standard. There is “we killed them off quite firmly but never say never,” which is what studios say when they want to keep a door open while the actor negotiates. And then there is “dead dead,” which is what Sarah Michelle Gellar has said about her character Helen Shivers in the upcoming I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel.
For those who need the recap: Gellar appeared in the 1997 original as Helen, a beauty queen whose death scene — in a street, at a hook, while people watched from windows above and did nothing — was and remains one of the more effectively staged kills in late-’90s slasher cinema. It works because Gellar commits completely, and because the scene uses the helplessness of public space in a way the rest of the film does not quite manage.
The sequel, I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998), did not feature Gellar, for the obvious reason that Helen was dead. Dead dead, as it turns out — a designation Gellar has now applied retrospectively in an interview where she was asked, with some optimism, whether she might appear in the new film.
The answer was no. Cheerfully, definitively no. “Helen is dead dead,” she said, with the energy of someone who has been asked this question more than once and has arrived at exactly the right formulation for ending the conversation.
There is something refreshing about this. The current trend in legacy sequels and soft reboots is to leave every door technically ajar, to hedge every death, to maintain optionality. Gellar’s refusal to play along — she is busy, she has other projects, and also her character was murdered conclusively in 1997 — is quietly its own form of respect for the original film.
The new I Know What You Did Last Summer is in development. Helen will not be in it. The hook, presumably, will.
Leave a Reply